Classroom Guide for
by Bernard Wolf
You might consider using this book when discussing the observance of Mother’s Day, which falls in mid-May, and/or Father’s Day, which is celebrated in mid-June, with students.
Exploring the Book
Display the book cover and read aloud the title. Ask student what they expect to learn from the book. What story do they think the people in the cover photograph might tell?
Review the parts of the book including the dedication, title page, and afterword. Point out the copyright date (found on page 2) and mention that the children in the Mahmoud family would now be several years older.
Setting a Purpose for Reading
Have students read to find out what life is like for a Muslim family that has recently moved to the United States.
You will want to be sensitive to the specific experiences of any students who are recent immigrants or whose parents are still struggling to adapt to life in the United States. Encourage these students to think about and make comparisons between their stories and the one they will read about.
Write the following words and phrases on the chalkboard and tell students that the words/phrases are related to the immigrant experience. Have students explore the meaning of each and then use it in a written sentence. Challenge students to add other words related to the immigrant experience to the list.
|native language||foreign||extended family|
READING AND RESPONDING
After students have read the book, use these or similar questions to generate discussion, review comprehension, and develop students’ understanding of the book. Encourage students to refer to passages or photographs in the book to support their responses.
- Why did Hassan Mahmoud come to the United States? Why did he come alone? Why might this be a common thing for many immigrants to do?
- What are Hassan’s dreams and goals? What are the dreams and goals of his wife and children?
- Are the children’s dreams and goals similar to or different from the things you and your friends dream about and want to do?
- Why is prayer an important part of the day for the Mahmouds?
- Why is school easier for Amr in the United States than in Egypt? How is school here different for Dina?
- How do you think Rowan feels about life in America? What does she miss about her old neighborhood in Alexandria?
- How does Hassan’s job affect his life and the life of his family?
- What is the main meal of the day like for the Mahmoud family?
- Why do you think education means so much to the family?
- Why is it important for Soad to go back to school?
- What are the things that give the family comfort and strength?
If you use literature circles during reading time, students might find the following suggestions helpful in developing the roles of the circle members.
- The Questioner might use questions similar to those in the Discussion Question section of this guide.
- The Passage Locator might look for passages that tell about the struggles the family faces to make a new life in a new country.
- The Illustrator might draw scenes of the family’s arrival in the United States, or other parts of the story that are not illustrated by the photographs.
- The Connector might find other books about immigrant families.
- The Summarizer should provide a brief summary of the group’s reading and discussion points for each meeting.
- The Investigator might find books about contemporary life in Egypt.
There are many resource books available with more information about organizing and implementing literature circles. Three such books you may wish to refer to are: Getting Started with Literature Circles by Katherine L. Schlick Noe and Nancy J. Johnson (Christopher-Gordon, 1999), Literature Circles: Voice And Choice in Book Clubs and Reading Groups by Harvey Daniels (Stenhouse, 2002), and Literature Circles Resource Guide by Bonnie Campbell Hill, Katherine L. Schlick Noe, and Nancy J. Johnson (Christopher-Gordon, 2000).
Use the following questions or similar ones to help students practice active reading and personalize what they have read. Suggest that students respond in reader’s journals, oral discussion, or drawings.
- What are some things you would like to ask the Mahmouds about their religion or traditional customs?
- How well do you think the Mahmouds are doing in becoming members of their new community in the United States? Give examples.
- How well is the family doing in keeping alive their own customs? Give examples.
- Why might it be important for them to do both?
- What do you admire about people like the Mahmouds, who leave a place and people they know well to move to someplace far away and very different from what they know? Why?
Other Writing Activities
You may wish to have students participate in one or more of the following writing activities. Set aside time for them to share and discuss their work.
- Have students write a few paragraphs in which they compare and contrast their family life with that of the Mahmouds. Students might first make a chart to identify points of comparison.
- Tell students to imagine they are Rowan. Then ask them to write an e-mail or a letter to a friend in Alexandria telling about her day.
- Let students make a birthday or graduation card for Amr. Have them include a note in it congratulating him.
- Have students research things that the Mahmouds might do or see in New York City during summer vacation. Have them prepare a list with descriptions of each possible activity.
- The Mahmouds came from Egypt. Have students talk about where their families are from. Are they from some other place in the United States, or from another country? Encourage students to interview a family member to find out about where their family is from, and then write a description of it.
ELL/ESL Teaching Strategies
These strategies might be helpful to use with students who are learning to speak English as a second language.
- Make a chart showing different words from the book in English and in other languages spoken by students in the class. Post the chart in a prominent place.
- Use the photographs in the book as clues to help make key words concrete.
- Show students how to use the photographs as an aide to comprehending the story.
- If students are having difficulty with verb tenses, use a calendar to help them understand when to use the past, present, or future.
- Locate Egypt on a map or globe. Have students answer questions such as:
- On what continent is Egypt?
- What bodies of water border it?
- What is its major river?
- What is the capital of Egypt?
- What countries are Egypt’s neighbors?
- Students might research and write reports about Islam. Suggest that they start with the facts in the Afterword of Coming to America and then find other information in books and on the Internet. Students might present their reports using maps, posters, photographs, or other visual materials.
- Remind students that Hassan, the father in this story, works at night in a grocery store that is open twenty-four hours a day. Ask students to brainstorm a list of other jobs that people do at night. Compile a list on the chalkboard, then discuss why these night jobs are necessary. If possible, have students interview someone who has a night job and report their findings to the class.
Food and Nutrition
Have students review the text to make a list of foods that the family eats. If possible, find some simple recipes for Middle Eastern dishes that students might try in class or at home with their families.
Collect menus from restaurants in your community that offer different ethnic foods. Make a bulletin board display featuring menus and recipes of various cultures that students might enjoy trying.
Chico hopes to stay at his school long enough to take part in the Math Fair. Organize a class Math Fair for your students. Encourage students to think of activities to include at the fair.
Art and Religion
Have students work in groups to make a mural showing different places of worship, such as mosques, temples, churches, and synagogues, that are used by various religions. Students might also include symbols or artifacts related to each religion.
About the Author and Photographer
Bernard Wolf is a photojournalist who lives in New York City. He has traveled extensively and has had his camera aimed at the world for many years. Wolf’s first book, The Little Weaver of Agato, was published in 1969. Since then he has produced candid explorations of many serious social issues and other cultures. In 1981, during the International Year of Disabled Persons, Wolf was honored by the American Library Association for his books featuring children with disabilities. More recent books include Cuba: After the Revolution and HIV Positive. Wolf has also had photographs in publications such as Time, Life, National Geographic, Fortune, New York, and Travel/Holiday.
Resources on the Web
Download this guide in PDF
Learn more about Coming to America
BookTalk with Bernard Wolf