I Am Alfonso Jones
Review
By Foreword Reviews
Tony Medina tackles the issue of race and police brutality, in the unique, teen-friendly graphic novel I Am Alfonso Jones. Alfonso Jones, a black teenager, is killed by an off-duty police officer who mistakes a coat hanger in Alfonso’s hand for a gun. Alfonso had been studying Hamlet in school, and Medina uses the conceit of ghosts relating information to educate Alfonso about the long history of police shootings and abuse against black people as he meets with many such victims in the afterlife. Alfonso learns even as he silently watches his family, friends, and even the police officer who shot him deal with the aftermath of his death. It’s a complicated and controversial topic, and Medina does a good job of balancing practical advice (one character provides a list of “rules” for dealing with the police, including “don’t run”) even while pointing out that seemingly harmless violations (like running away) don’t justify fatal violence. Medina’s characterizations are detailed and appealing, using language natural to teens, and his kinetic art forcefully conveys the myriad emotions that the book’s subject raises. The use of actual victims’ stories makes Alfonso’s fictional tale ring all too true. Alfonso’s class goes on to adapt Hamlet as a hip-hop play, and the bits that Medina shows are intriguing enough that he might consider a full hip-hop graphic novel adaptation. I Am Alfonso Jones, meanwhile, stands as a valuable tool for educating young people about the history of police injustice.
Reviews & Comments
School Library Journal
Kirkus Reviews
Booklist
Publishers Weekly
The Horn Book Magazine
Library Journal
The Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books
Forbes
Teen Librarian Toolbox, School Library Journal
VOYA
YA Books Central
Gene Luen Yang, National Ambassador for Young People’s Literature and author of AMERICAN BORN CHINESE and BOXERS AND SAINTS
LeVar Burton, Actor, Director, Author, and Reading Activist
Daniel José Older, author of SHADOWSHAPER and SHADOWHOUSE FALL
Nikki Giovanni
Randy DuBurke, illustrator of YUMMY: THE LAST DAYS OF A SOUTHSIDE SHORTY
Ibi Zoboi, author of AMERICAN STREET
Katheryn Russell-Brown, University of Florida Law professor, Director, UF Center for the Study of Race and Race Relations, and author of LITTLE MELBA AND HER BIG TROMBONE
Frederick Luis Aldama, author of LONG STORIES CUT SHORT: FICTIONS FROM THE BORDERLANDS and LATINX SUPERHEROES IN MAINSTREAM COMICS
Tanita Davis, author of PEAS AND CARROTS and MARE'S WAR
Allie Jane Bruce, Children's Librarian, Bank Street College and co-founder of Reading While White